Top non-winning qualifier performances of 2008

A list of all non-winning 15+ qualifier results follows after the jump. Mike Fitzgerald was the competitor with the best total who did not qualify for the finals. There were 31 non-winning result larger than Kevin Ross’ 17.75 total at the California qualifier, including one by Kevin Ross himself.

2008 May 10 2nd 30 Patrick Vandam Apple Valley, MN
2008 May 17 2nd 28.5 Tim “Gravy” Brown Matteson, IL
2008 Jun 14 2nd 24.5 Allen “Shredder” Goldstein Queens, NY
2008 May 10 3rd 23.5 Mike Fitzgerald Apple Valley, MN
2008 May 31 2nd 23 Chris “The Mad Greek” Abatsas Overland Park, KS
2008 May 17 3rd 22.75 Mike Fitzgerald Matteson, IL
2008 Jun 26 2nd 22 Micah “Wing Kong” Collins West Chester, PA
2008 Jun 28 2nd 22 “Buffalo” Jim Reeves Camden, NJ
2008 May 8 2nd 21 Ron Koch Las Vegas, NV
2008 May 31 3rd 21 Nic “The Incredible Bulk” Fry Overland Park, KS
2008 Jun 14 3rd 21 Pat “from Moonachie” Philbin Queens, NY
2008 Jun 14 4th 20.5 Yasir Salem Queens, NY
2008 Jun 28 3rd 20.25 Eric “Steakbellie” Livingston Camden, NJ
2008 Jun 7 2nd 20 Russ “The Black Hole” Keeler Norfolk, VA
2008 May 24 2nd 20 Sean “Flash” Gordon Philadelphia, PA
2008 Jun 21 2nd 20 Kevin Ross Plano, TX
2008 May 31 4th 20 Pat Bruss Overland Park, KS
2008 May 24 2nd 19.75 “Buffalo” Jim Reeves Greensburg, PA
2008 Jun 7 3rd 19.75 William Schierer Norfolk, VA
2008 May 17 2nd 19.5 Russ “The Black Hole” Keeler East Hartford, CT
2008 Jun 7 4th 19.5 Joe Tursi Norfolk, VA
2008 Jun 14 5th 19.5 “Nasty” Nathan Biller Queens, NY
2008 May 24 3rd 19 Micah “Wing Kong” Collins Greensburg, PA
2008 Jun 28 4th 19 Yasir Salem Camden, NJ
2008 Jun 14 6th 18.5 Scott “Scozzy Bone” Zukowski Queens, NY
2008 Jun 21 2nd 18.5 Loren “Bubba” Yarbrough Atlanta, GA
2008 Jun 21 3rd 18 Ken Mansfield Plano, TX
2008 Jun 14 2nd 18 Todd Hennessey Charlotte, NC
2008 Jun 28 5th 18 Dave “U. S. Male” Goldstein Camden, NJ
2008 Jun 28 5th 18 Micah “Wing Kong” Collins Camden, NJ
2008 Jun 28 5th 18 Sean “Flash” Gordon Camden, NJ
2008 May 10 4th 17.5 Frank “the Kaiser” Wach Apple Valley, MN
2008 May 24 4th 17 “Big” Brian Subich Greensburg, PA
2008 Jun 26 3rd 17 Eric “Steakbellie” Livingston West Chester, PA
2008 Jun 14 7th 17 Jack Densing Queens, NY
2008 May 10 5th 17 Russell “Mad Stork” Witzke Apple Valley, MN
2008 Jun 21 3rd 17 Larry “The Legend” McNeil Atlanta, GA
2008 May 24 4th 17 Eric “Steakbellie” Livingston Greensburg, PA
2008 Jun 7 2nd 17 Peter Parker New Orleans, LA
2008 May 17 3rd 17 Jon “jcrue” Taylor East Hartford, CT
2008 May 17 4th 16.5 Peter “Pretty Boy” Davekos East Hartford, CT
2008 Jun 26 4th 16 Jack Densing West Chester, PA
2008 Jun 21 2nd 16 Damon Serignet Myrtle Beach, SC
2008 May 24 3rd 16 Russ “The Black Hole” Keeler Philadelphia, PA
2008 Jun 7 3rd 16 Damon Serignet New Orleans, LA
2008 Jun 21 4th 15 Timm “The InTimmidator” Dilling Plano, TX
2008 Jun 14 8th 15 “Beautiful” Brian Seiken Queens, NY
2008 Jun 26 5th 15 William “Wild Bill” Myers West Chester, PA
2008 Jun 21 4th 15 Chris Floyd Plano, TX
2008 May 17 5th 15 Mike Springer East Hartford, CT
2008 Jun 26 5th 15 Dave “U. S. Male” Goldstein West Chester, PA

Comments (9)

9 Comments »

  1. anonymous fan said

    June 29, 2008 @ 9:08 am

    You should do the same chart, but delete the competitors that did eventually make it to the finals. It would be easier to see.

  2. Carey said

    June 29, 2008 @ 9:18 am

    What’s the point of this thread? I think the fact that Kevin himself got a considerably higher total before shows that he just didn’t want to push himself when he didn’t need to. Why risk a reversal when you don’t have to. Kevin deserves the win.

  3. Anonymous said

    June 29, 2008 @ 11:17 am

    Some people may argue, that you should push yourself to your limit every time during competition. that’s what the best will always do.

  4. Philly Guy said

    June 29, 2008 @ 2:50 pm

    If he reversed, someone that did 11 would get in. The better eater made it in that day and that’s all that matters.

  5. Carey said

    June 30, 2008 @ 8:12 am

    The best do that? Both Kobayoshi and Chestnut have held back in competitions when they had a solid lead. It isn’t “the best” strategy to just push yourself as hard as you can, it is stupidity.

  6. WingKong said (Registered December 19, 2006)

    June 30, 2008 @ 9:23 am

    Hey did I miss something, where did the wild card go???? I’m a victim of circumstance!!!!

  7. Mega Munch said

    June 30, 2008 @ 10:02 am

    What is the best strategy when you’ve got a win locked down? Push hard and eat as much as possible or only eat what you need to secure the win? The question reminds me of the “running up the scoreboard” debates in other pro sports (usually football and basketball).

    If a team has a big lead and the win is guaranteed, it’s considered good sportsmanship to go easy and not heap unnecessary points on the scoreboard or risk injuring your players by running aggressive plays. Granted, that situation has more to do with helping your opponent save face by not rubbing salt in the wound caused by the lopsided score, but it’s a similar situation nonetheless.

    Personally, I think an eater should still push hard, but hold back a little bit if the win is locked down. That strategy makes even more sense when you realize what’s on the line in some contests. Sometimes it’s thousands of dollars or, in this case, a priceless trip to Coney Island.

  8. Steakbellie said (Registered August 11, 2006)

    June 30, 2008 @ 10:03 am

    If the Wild Card was suddenly brought back, Wing Kong would lead the pack of those who completed 3 Qualifiers. Sorry buddy, not your year.

  9. nic "TheIncredibleBulk" fry said

    July 2, 2008 @ 8:31 pm

    First time i ever even tasted a nathans hotdog or eat for speed…. i think some of you are in trouble next year

RSS feed for comments on this post

Leave a Comment

Log in | Register | Comments by users who have not logged in will be held for approval